
Kincaid, Edwards, and Bazterrica
–In which I return to two previously enjoyed writers’ works, and “discover” one new-to-me writer.
Although… since the Winter Quarterly, my short story reading has been all over the place.
Usually I have a collection or two in my stacks, and I read a story most days.
In a month’s time, I read at least one collection—often two—even if I also read a few standalones in magazines.
However in recent months, I’ve had eight or ten collections in my stacks, so even though I’m reading just as many stories, I’m not finishing many collections. I’ve been wondering if reading more standalones in magazines, has contributed to my feeling more comfortable bouncing around between multiple collections. But I dunno if that’s it.
Sometimes it’s a little mysterious, how reading habits change; if this pattern continues, I will reconsider how I assemble these Quarterly posts but, for now, here’s a glimpse of the collections I’ve finished this spring.
Jamaica Kincaid’s At the Bottom of the River (1992) landed in my stacks because I realised that I’d not read her most recent two novels (Mr. Potter from 2002 and See Now Then from 2013) or these stories, seven of which were originally published in The New Yorker. In my stacks, these read more like poems than stories. Some, like “Girl” and “The Letter from Home” are just a couple pages long, but even the longer ones feel like poems arranged into paragraphs. The use of repetition begs for them to be read aloud, each sentence secured inside a bubble and rising collectively as you read on, until the story is held aloft. Lyricism is more prominent than narrative and, when you’ve finished, it’s easier to describe a feeling than what’s happened. But they feel deliberate, shaped. Perhaps only by an idea. Consider this passage from “What I Have Been doing Lately”, which seems to press all around the edges of time, particularly with the movement of the sun at the end:
“I walked for I don’t know how long before I came up to a big body of water. I wanted to get across it but I couldn’t swim. I wanted to get across it but it would take me years to build a boat. I wanted to get across it but it would take me I didn’t know how long to build a bridge. Years passed and then one day, feeling like it, I got into my boat and rowed across. When I got to the other side, it was noon and my shadow was small and fell beneath me.”
Contents: Girl; In the Night; At Last; Wingless; Holidays; the Letter from Home; What I Have Been Doing Lately; Blackness; My Mother; At the Bottom of the River

Dorothy Edwards’ Rhapsody (1927) was one of my earliest Virago Modern Classics, collected as much because of the musical theme as the imprint, which I’d barely begun to explore. It’s been on my shelves for so long that I had forgotten about her suicide, although it’s clearly mentioned on the back cover (her note reproduced in Elaine Morgan’s introduction), which I read when I was halfway through. Previously, her outside-looking-in characters had felt only bemused and unsure—sometimes lonely but, in that context, they suddenly seemed melancholic and isolated. But the other characters seem to be living in quite a different story, with plenty of talk of art and songs and symphonies, There are parcels wrapped in brown paper and mushrooms to forage, there are wildflowers gathered and presented, and neighbours to visit with granddaughters who fall quickly in love with visiting strangers. If you value seemingly simple stories that reward rereading, and you appreciate what’s left unsaid, Dorothy Edwards will suit you very well. (Pictured alongside: her biography.)
“She flushed a little and turned away. Of course he had no objection to lending her a book, but he knew that most women only talk about reading, and that is merely the preliminary to talking about love.”
Contents: Rhapsody, A Country House, The Conquered, Treachery in a Forest, Cultivated People, Summer-time, Sweet Grapes, A Garland of Earth, A Throne in Heaven, Days
The back cover of Agustina Bazterrica’s Nineteen Claws and a Black Bird (2020; Trans. Sarah Moses, 2023) is plastered with praise for Tender Is the Flesh, which suggests that the collection was arranged after that slim novel’s tremendous success, rather than deliberately curated by the author. It’s clear that the stories are written with different artistic goals in mind. Some are very short and cultivate a particular mood, and several turn on an element of surprise; you can imagine these on the back page of a magazine. Some are longer, divided into parts, and designed to more fully explore an idea or situation; you can imagine these in the kind of anthology that gets published with a red ribbon as a bookmark. The girls and women in these stories are fierce; they field attacks from a variety of directions (even from within). In Bazterrica’s fiction, the kind of social commentary that characterises the horror genre is bent towards the risks that women navigate through misogyny (the first story is bloody, others less so). Sometimes there’s a whiff of fairy-tales-retold (as with Angela Carter) and sometimes a gentler-but-still-dark tone (as with Susanna Clarke). Always with an air of daring.
“But Anita was much more than that, which is why Pablo decided to fall in love with her, if only to confirm whether her apparent weakness could be hiding a mastermind capable of conquering the universe, or a tireless predator harassing the human race.”

Contents: Twenty stories (in only 154 pages), beginning with “A Light, Swift, and Monstrous Sound” and ending with “The Solitary Ones”
In other story reading, for this year’s #ReadIndies, I wrote aboutJann Everard’s Blue Runaways (2024), Danila Botha’s Things that Cause Inappropriate Happiness (2024), and Cyril Dabydeen’s Forgotten Exiles (2025). And, in my bookbag, was Kristen Zory King’s Ladies Ladies Ladies (2025). I wrote about Susie Taylor’s Vigil, published by the Canadian indie Breakwater Press, which I really loved. And, of course, Bill and Bron and I are continuing to read through the Russian short stories that Saunders teaches in A Swim in a Pond in the Rain (schedule here).
And, what about you, what’s the last short story you read? Or, from which of these collections would you choose to read a story, if it was just you and these three books in a locked room?
I’ve only read Kinkaid’s short stories but never her novels (even though I have a few on my bookshelves). I need to remedy that. I love how she has a lyrical way with words and how her stories are rich with Caribbean culture.
I just noticed she has a children’s book from 2024, as well as a couple of shorter books new-to-me (one about the Himalaya which sounds interesting).
I don’t think I’ve read a short story not in the New Yorker in a while. A couple of months ago I read A House on Mango Street–not sure how I’d missed that until now–which is kind of a story collection. Hmm.
This week’s looked promising (but, oh, what WAS it? /eyeroll) … I’ve fallen behind again too.
I read that one “late” too; I don’t know how I missed it either. Stefanie mentioned her poetry, too, not long ago, so I was thinking about reading some of that and rereading Mango Street alongside.
I’d read the Dorothy Edwards as I’ve also read Winter Sonata! She was very good at chronicling the ordinary. I’ve just read some poems, rather shockingly – review coming tomorrow!
And there’s Ali’s influence too: I know she’s one of her favourites too (perhaps not as favouritey as Whipple though)!
I’m curious: I’ll definitely have a look at your poetry review.
Your comment about appreciating what’s left unsaid in the Dorothy Edwards made me think of a recent interview with the filmmaker Wong Kar-wai, in which he describes ‘In the Mood for Love’ as film about absence – more specifically, what he decided to leave out: “The film is about absence. What’s missing is as important as what’s there.” For instance, he shot a sex scene between the two lead characters but decided to leave it out of the final cut. Sometimes, less is more…
Ahhhh, thanks Jacqui. I love that. Will look into it a little more. It’s a theme I look for. And probably part of the pull behind some of my “pet themes” too, like the hotel stories (which I know you enjoy, too). It’s as much about who stayed there before (now absent) and who will stay there, because the person the story is about is only one guest and they’ll likely check-out before very long (absent soon).
Er, it’s been so long since I’ve read a short story I can’t even tell you what it was. If it was me in a room and I had to go with one of these three collections, I’d choose Kincaid. I’ve read and enjoyed a couple of her not short story books 🙂
They have a poetry feel to them, so that’s a nice choice!
I had no idea that Virago had a Writers of Wales series. I’ve just started Mary South’s You Will Never Be Forgotten which is quite intriguing so far.
I’m sorry to be confusing; I included the cover of her biography thinking that anyone else who’d read her work would like to know about it, but only so briefly mentioned it that I can see how it was overlooked.
I’d happily try Kincaid. I see that I have a different one of her collections, which I’ve labelled “linked short stories,” on my TBR: Annie John.
I didn’t care for Bazterrica’s short fiction, but still look forward to getting to her newest novel.
Annie John will always be my favourite because it was my first. I thought of it as a novel, but I don’t think linked stories were A Thing then.
I’m so impressed by that novel and how she pulled me straight through before I even had time to THINK. But, now, I can’ shake it. (Good sign, I know.) I found that I appreciated the stories more when I allowed waaaaay more time than usual between them.
I *do* own a Dorothy Edwards Virago (I think…) – really must get to it sometime…
It’s one that Ali really loves as well. Now I must read Winter Sonata. [Edited because I wrote the wrong title!]
It’s been a while since I read Dorothy Edwards. I think I’ve got Rhapsody somewhere, you’ve encouraged me to dig it out!
I still flash back to scenes in those stories, months later, and I think they’d be even more affecting when read in summer.