But now for a summer book that I actually read out-of-season: I was entranced by Mireille Gagné’s Horsefly (2024), translated by Pablo Strauss the following year. (Published by Coach House in Canada, New Cross Press in England, La livre de Poche in France).
It’s turned a few heads, and it’s won a few awards, which would be good reason to recommend it. But one reason I want to recommend it, is that I don’t have a single clear reason for recommending it, because it’s not a book that’s easy to define or categorise.
I’ve seen some marketing categories, while checking out the world rights (to see if I was about to recommend a book to international readers who can’t easily access Canadian indies) but although none are inaccurate, somehow they don’t quite feel wholly satisfactory either. There’s one blurb that I really like, but I’m sure that a few of you would read that blurb and think “nope, that’s not a book for me” but that you’d be swept away by the story. Horsefly is hard to pin down.
What’s not debatable: it’s 150 pages long in the Canadian edition, and presented in a striking way with full-page images marking the individual segments of story. Which is to say that it could read very quickly. Maybe in an afternoon even. Which is always remarkable, but particularly in seasonal extremes, if you are lucky enough to have the leisure to simply sit for a few hours and enter an imagined world.
(But that’s not how I read it. Instead, I mostly read a single section on a series of days, but allowed myself to read the final two sections together. Immediately I felt as though I wanted to linger on what Gagné was about… whatever that proved to be… to just let it hang in the air, despite being almost undeniably curious about where it was all going, and therefore not wanting to rush.)
It’s also undeniable that there is an historical element to the story, with an important part of it set in 1942 Quebec. Because it matters that it’s wartime: that power is to be secured and wielded, that sacrifices will be made in the name of progress and victory. This one plot element is easily summarised, but the novel is also about how family ties are maintained and strained, about friendships and clubbing, and about what changes (and doesn’t) across a handful of decades: from the day-to-day work required to cover the cost of food and housing, to the sweep to historical trends and patterns.
There are lacklustre moments that focus on the effort required to do a job when you’re tired and overdrawn, outrageous moments that seem to belong to a thriller, and tender moments that had me teary. I don’t mean to say that this slim novel will satisfy all the dedicated workplace-novel lovers, the thriller aficionados, and the sentimental readers, but that it’s a novel that a wide variety of readers could enjoy, not despite it being strange and surprising but because it’s strange and surprising.
Gagné’s prose is spare and it feels like an editorial eye has circled across the manuscript countless times, hovering over every single, potentially extraneous word. Throughout, it’s a sweaty and moist story. There’s dampness in the creases of the book’s spine, a drone in the background that you’ll drown out with a fan (if you’re lucky) or a heater (if it’s winter right now).
What surprised me most… well, I can’t say that. And I can’t say the thing that next-most surprised me either.
But I can say that, after those things, I was surprised that I wanted to keep and reread my copy, because I had all the same hesitations that you might be having right now (if you’ve read the blurbs or the summaries).
And summer is my least favourite season, but I’d stick my feet in a cool tub of water to reread what Mireille Gagné’s done here. And maybe I could figure out how to talk about it without spoiling any of it either.


Oooh, this sounds creepy, but in an amount that I could handle, ha ha! And the short length definitely appeals. I’ll keep it in mind!
Heheh Yeah, it’s… manageable creepy? Not overwhelming creepy? But, also, moist creepy…
As you know I often get caught up on trying to pin a book down too, but you had me by ‘strange and surprising’.
And thanks to Bill’s comment I will see how quickly I can order a copy in at work today (although I’ve just remembered their distribution company has been hit by a major hacking/interference brouhaha, so I may have to reach out to the rep instead…either way, I’m onto it!)
I’ve been thinking even more than usual about how the way that books are discussed impacts my expectations, which probably goes back to George Saunders heightening the attention I pay to what’s in my mind about a story before I even begin reading it and how it changes once I pick up the book in my own hands and move through the story.
Ahhh, that’s unfortunate: these h*cking incidents so often revolve around minimising public/community access to books and information. I hope they can recover before too long and without too much trouble.
You have certainly intrigued me, with your I-don’t-want-to-call-it-this-or-that-ness! Also you description of its spareness reminded me of reading about Claire Keegan who goes through her work again and again removing words, even after something has been published and is going to be republished, apparently. But, I just look at my shelves and say no, not right now.
She does strike me as someone who would be very attentive to that kind of detail. And Gagnier does write in a similar style and maybe there are some themes in common too: but I’m not trying to convince you, just saying. I’ve recently started a new collection by a Canadian writer and I can already tell she’s that sort of writer too. If you ever do crave something like this, it would make for an interesting companion to Anna, for its is-it-genre or is-it-historical or is-it-forecasting…
This does indeed sound rather strange and surprising – in a good way, I should add!
The image on that first cover is very striking – I’d certainly pick it up in a bookshop for a closer look…
The style would appeal to you, I think. And the undercurrent. I can’t think of something else you’ve read like this, but you were definitely one of the readers I thought would appreciate how it comes together (and doesn’t).
I could see myself liking this book, especially because of the illustrations! It sounds fun. What shocked me about your review is the fact that summer is your least favourite season? In Canada????
Winter is my favourite favouritest (but, as I menioned in the previous post, I’ve had four favourites… #fickle). Feel free to expound about how wrong I am. hee hee
The illustration repeats, so it’s not exactly entertaining–simply suitable (it would be spoilery to mention). You could add this one to your new Sept/Oct pile, but I’ll say no more. /handovermouth
This is a very intriguing and tempting review! I’m so pleased its available here too.
I was so happy to see it’s found a home in multiple houses, and I hope her versatility gains her many readers in many places.
I moved to Babelio to read the blurb in French (Frappabord is the title in French) I hadn’t heard from it before. I’m not sure it’s a book for me but it is intriguing. Another shout out for French-Canadian lit!
I think I know the parts in the description that would make you think it’s not for you; all I can say, is that I think the part that nobody is talking about is definitely to your reading taste.
Horsefly is available in Australia from NewSouth Books and also on Kindle which (sadly) is how I bought it. NewSouth don’t have an ebook option.
I am intrigued by your recommendation without description so I have resisted reading any blurbs. Hopefully I’ll get to it in the next month or so.
Maybe this is a dumb question, but because I can’t read epubs I rarely buy them: is it not possible to buy the ebook from, say, Coach House? Is this a rights issue?
I’m curious which part of the story jumps out of you, as I can see why each could seem the most important depending on one’s taste. And it frustrates me that I still want to isolate one of them, and say “it’s a ______ novel” even though it’s more than any one kind of story.
Every now and then I will attempt to buy an ebook on a US site and be told get back to where you came from – ie. they don’t hold the rights outside N America.
And also, I’m wary when prices are in USD what conversion rate to AUD will be used and if there’ll be an extra fee.
I wonder if that’s why one occasionally sees “world rights’ now, whereas that seemed unheard of previously, specifically to make epub sales uncomplicated. It’s hard to track how tech changes certain selling/buying habits sometimes.
I’m forever getting hit with extra fees using P*yp*l (which some indie presses and mag’s here rely on); I dither every time, reluctant to take the chance.
I have not heard of this book so I went and looked it up after reading what you wrote and being intrigued. It sounds really interesting. Sadly my library doesn’t have it though I may be able to get it through interlibrary loan sometime.
I don’t want to spoil anything, obviously, but there is an aspect to the story that I think would particularly appeal to you from a political/ environmental perspective. However, I also know you have a tonne of ILL options already!
I feel like I might have downloaded this from Edelweiss? I’ll check my Kindle! I’d likely earmark it for Novellas in November, although horseflies sure do make me think of the swimming pool at summer camp. I literally put my feet in a bucket of ice water at my nephew’s graduation party when I was afraid I’d burned just from glancing sunlight while I was sat in the shade by the pool to read.
It seems possible with more than one publisher in the mix, and it would be great for #novnov too! Heheh, yes, it is literally a relief. It’s one of my last-resort techniques, but it probably won’t be much longer before the buckets are in service.
Intriguing! I’ve read a blurb for the first edition you’ve illustrated which is very different from the second. Anyway, the good news is it’s available in the UK.
If the part of the plot that is rooted in history was news to me, I’m sure it would be the same for you: either way, I’m happy it’s available overseas (in the UK and France, at least…maybe more)!