But, first, it’s MA’s 87th birthday. Here’s a recipe for her favourite cake: go wild! (I’ll post photos of my substandard, my-heart’s-in-the-right-place substitute lemon cake next time.) Or light a candle for her in another treat, send a sincere little wish or good thought: HAPPY BIRTHDAY!
Talk of the generations in the previous post reminded me of the part in MA’s memoir, Book of Lives, where she talks about how Canadian writers began to see themselves as distinct. About how the idea of Canadians being part of the British empire and everyone fighting together in WWII faded, how it would become possible to see oneself as a Canadian writer—and not like the truly exceptional Mazo de la Roche or Morley Callaghan—but by attracting particular sorts of readers.
In 1944, when Gwethalyn Graham published Earth and High Heaven, she had tremendous success because she also found an audience in America (her story of a Jewish man and non-Jewish woman falling in love was scandalous for its day). But isn’t it ironic that it was readers from somewhere else that not only bought her book, but drew attention to the ways in which Canadian and American societies were similar/different.

In 1947, Gabrielle Roy’s The Tin Flute, said “working class” on the cover and “talked energetically about economic and social inequalities” and looked forward to a “just society”. It would take another twenty years, MA says, for a politician to utter those words (Pierre Trudeau, Justin’s dad. (And just saying it wasn’t enough: one of the books she recommends in the chapter about Indigenous characters and authors is Harold Cardinal’s The Unjust Society.) In the post-war years, this also attracted readers.
With Canadian novels like these, publishers still might not make money off the hardcovers but, with the rise in popularity of the paperback, and the marketing model shifting, they could compensate for that loss with paperback sales. So things were beginning to change. People could afford more books, and people were taking notice of who was writing them.
MARM 2026 PLANS
Launch (November 1)
Survival: One, Two, Three (November 4)
Week Two: Update and Check-In (November 8)
Survival: Four, Five, Six (November 11)
Week Three: Update and Check-In (November 15)
Margaret Atwood’s 87th Birthday (November 18)
Survival: Seven, Eight, Nine (November 18)
Week Four: Update and Check-In (November 22)
Survival: Ten, Eleven, Twelve (November 25)
Wrap-Up (November 30)
To the point where, in MA’s fourth/final year at college, a course on the modern novel (“a kind of dessert”) included two experimental books by Canadian women (“a double espresso”): The Double Hook by Sheila Watson and Mad Shadows, by Marie-Claire Blais. They weren’t included because they were Canadian though, but because they were experimental. (Both are listed in Survival, but in next week’s chapters.)
In Book of Lives, she begins to see how the world was changing and making a space in which the identity of a “Canadian writer” could take shape, and in which she could find a place for herself in it (like Marie-Claire Blais, who was two years younger than MA and had ambitions in both poetry and prose, had done).
FAILED SACRIFICES: CHAPTER SEVEN
More talk of the generations here, with novels about the immigrant experience. On my last reread, this chapter inspired me to read John Marlyn’s Under the Ribs of Death, about Hungarian immigrants who resettled in Winnipeg, Manitoba. It recounts the story of the second generation (bullied for his differences as a child and forced to make unacceptable decisions to avoid poverty throughout his life), but most of the novels referenced in this chapter include all three generations.
“The first generation of the immigrant novel is typically seen as having more charm and wisdom, or vitality, or cultural suavity, than its WASP counterpart; the second generation has more energy—it really fights for success—and the third generation is given a better chance for a full human life.” (Once again, her examples don’t neatly fit her thesis in every way, so I carry on thinking that she wants readers to think and not necessarily agree.)
THE CASUAL INCIDENCE OF DEATH: CHAPTER EIGHT
This chapter nestles with the second chapter’s talk of how deaths in American and English literature are different from those in Canadian stories. The short list includes two long poems and two plays, two of which feature Indigenous leaders, and this leads to an interesting discussion about national heroes. (Is the PM of Canada a hero, if he gets the railway built and puts a Métis leader to death because his fighting for landrights threatened to disrupt that progress? As a schoolgirl, I was taught the PM was the hero; at university, there were books which represented the First Nations’ perspective—as it was termed then.)
“The Canadian way of death is death by accident. Death by Nature has already been discussed in Chapter Two; those that drown, freeze or fall off mountains are usually seen as victims, of circumstance or of the environment, both by their authors and by the characters within the poem or novel. The victims may acquire a certain stature by their courage and dignity in the face of death, but the deaths themselves are senseless and accomplish nothing.”
THE PARALYZED ARTIST: CHAPTER NINE
Referring to E.K. Brown’s “The Problem of a Canadian Literature” and Hugh MacLennan’s “Boy Meets Girl in Winnipeg: Who Cares?”, MA points out that Americans were good little colonial subjects with their reading for a long time too. They had plenty of good writers coming up there, while everyone was reading Charles Dickens! But, even so, partly because the population was so much greater in the United States and England, publishers encouraged Canadian writers to set their books elsewhere, and to court the markets elsewhere.

“The solution, for some, has been escape, leaving a country in which it seems impossible to sustain oneself as an artist. Given that the Canadian artist is frozen, paralyzed, does flight unfreeze them?”
Here, MA has fun drawing a parallel between Graeme Gibson’s Five Legs and James Joyce’s Portrait—an allusion I missed, along with a hundred others I’m sure (I read Five Legs a few years ago, just tickled to find on the page a small Ontario city I’d lived in) and I definitely didn’t grasp the references to Brown’s article about whether it was worthwhile for a writer to set his book set Canada.
One thing that came to mind while reading these chapters was an interview with Annie Proulx some years ago (I won’t say when or why, because this is spoilery) wherein the interviewer introduced the topic of two deaths in her work, for which she’d received many complaints. She was impatient. First, she replied that proportionately that sort of death wasn’t the norm in her stories. Second, she said that lives sometimes ended abruptly, without warning, because sometimes that’s how people die. (Readers had objected because they’d gotten attached.)
The kind of death? An accident. These are more often end-times scenarios for Canadian novelists, in the Survival rubric, but here’s Proulx, who was born in Connecticut, with her mother’s ancestors dating to Mayflower-days. But, wait: on her father’s side? French-Canadian! And Proulx’s The Shipping News is set in Newfoundland, Canada (and some readers felt she captured the landscape and its people better than Newfoundland writers had to date). So she’s representing two teams and has the deaths to prove it.
I’m just playing: I don’t believe one should take these ideas verbatim, but that they are offered so that we can test them as readers, against our own experiences. But I hadn’t really thought so much about power dynamics contained in how authors dispatch their characters, and that has brought new insight to another book I’ve been reading while rereading Survival (James Welch’s Fool’s Crow, which also has a whole lot to say about colonization and imperialism).
If you’re reading along, I’m curious if any of the books to which MA refers to has piqued your curiosity to the point where you’ve gone looking, either for information or copies.
Margaret Atwood
“So many things are so much more depressing than me right now that I come across as actually quite bouncy.”
Margaret Atwood | On with Kara Swisher (December 2025)
Happy birthday Margaret. The cake recipe sounds fun (though not for me as a vegan…)